In circulated grades the 1924-D is a difficult coin to obtain. The dates wore off easily on the quarters of 1916 to 1924, as that was one of the highest points of MacNeil's design. Many are the EF sharpness coins with only a partial date in evidence. To own a sharp specimen with full date details practically requires obtaining a Mint State specimen.

The example to the left was sold by Stack's Bowers Galleries in the November 2010 Baltimore Auction, where it realized $9,775.